This report is part of a series, Learning in a Covid-19 World. The series focuses on how the education sector responded to the many challenges presented by Covid-19. Reports in the series share lessons learned over the course of the pandemic so far.
We spoke to learners, whÄnau, kaiako, kaimahi, leaders, hapĹŤ, and iwi representatives. We identified best practices and challenges the MÄoriâmedium education sector faced.
We found that the MÄori-medium education sector successfully joined forces with their communities. They responded quickly to the many challenges presented by Covid-19. They went above and beyond for learners, whÄnau, hapĹŤ and iwi.
This experience enhanced many learnersâ wellbeing and engagement in learning.
Leaders and kaiako worked closely with learners and their whÄnau. This included staying connected through high levels of whanaungatanga and manaakitanga.
Leaders reported a rise in learner and whÄnau engagement through distance learning. This was despite a âdigital divideâ, and lack of other resources that learners would normally need.
The many lessons learned in MÄori-medium education could influence English-medium education. This influence could enhance MÄori achieving educational success as MÄori.
What we learned could optimise learner engagement and wellbeing across the sector. Our findings could serve as a guide in future responses to unprecedented events.
This report is part of a series, Learning in a Covid-19 World. The series focuses on how the education sector responded to the many challenges presented by Covid-19. Reports in the series share lessons learned over the course of the pandemic so far.
We spoke to learners, whÄnau, kaiako, kaimahi, leaders, hapĹŤ, and iwi representatives. We identified best practices and challenges the MÄoriâmedium education sector faced.
We found that the MÄori-medium education sector successfully joined forces with their communities. They responded quickly to the many challenges presented by Covid-19. They went above and beyond for learners, whÄnau, hapĹŤ and iwi.
This experience enhanced many learnersâ wellbeing and engagement in learning.
Leaders and kaiako worked closely with learners and their whÄnau. This included staying connected through high levels of whanaungatanga and manaakitanga.
Leaders reported a rise in learner and whÄnau engagement through distance learning. This was despite a âdigital divideâ, and lack of other resources that learners would normally need.
The many lessons learned in MÄori-medium education could influence English-medium education. This influence could enhance MÄori achieving educational success as MÄori.
What we learned could optimise learner engagement and wellbeing across the sector. Our findings could serve as a guide in future responses to unprecedented events.
Ko te tamaiti te pĹŤtake o te kaupapa.
Quality education is the right of every child and young person
in Aotearoa and is underpinned by learning environments that place the learner and learner outcomes at the centre of all activity.
Successful learning organisations are those that are
on a continuous, deliberate and future-focused journey of improvement, using evidence to shape their direction and decision making.
Te Pou Mataaho, EROâs evaluation and research group, and Te UepĹŤ Ä Motu, EROâs national evaluation and review team, pursued this evaluation to provide an evidence base about the initial impacts of Covid-19 on MÄori-medium education and how the sector responded.
The evaluation approach has been designed by MÄori, with MÄori, for MÄori and in te reo MÄori. It respectfully acknowledges and validates the underlying principles of the differing provisions of MÄori-medium education for Te RĹŤnanga Nui o NgÄ Kura Kaupapa MÄori o Aotearoa, NgÄ Kura Ä Iwi o Aotearoa, KĹhanga Reo, Puna Reo and Whare KĹhungahunga, and operates in accordance with these. The above are referred to as peak bodies throughout this report. Information was gathered from learners, whÄnau, kaiako, kaimahi, leaders, hapĹŤ, and iwi representatives.
The MÄori-medium sector has continued to show great success in providing for tamariki MÄori and their whÄnau. The findings demonstrate how those within the sector successfully joined forces with their communities to respond quickly to the many challenges presented by Covid-19, and went above and beyond for learners, whÄnau, hapĹŤ and iwi.
This research found that many learners have come through this period of crisis with their wellbeing and engagement
in learning enhanced by the experience. Leaders and kaiako supported learners and their whÄnau by working with them and remaining connected to them through high levels of whanaungatanga and manaakitanga. Despite the inequities experienced due to a lack of resources and the âdigital divideâ, leaders reported a rise in learner and whÄnau engagement through distance learning.
This report has the potential to be far reaching and can influence the entire education sector. It can serve as a guide to optimising learner engagement and wellbeing in future responses to unprecedented events. Furthermore, the many lessons learnt in MÄori-medium education
can potentially influence English-medium teaching and learning in the future to enhance MÄori achieving educational success as MÄori.
Ko te tamaiti te pĹŤtake o te kaupapa.
Quality education is the right of every child and young person
in Aotearoa and is underpinned by learning environments that place the learner and learner outcomes at the centre of all activity.
Successful learning organisations are those that are
on a continuous, deliberate and future-focused journey of improvement, using evidence to shape their direction and decision making.
Te Pou Mataaho, EROâs evaluation and research group, and Te UepĹŤ Ä Motu, EROâs national evaluation and review team, pursued this evaluation to provide an evidence base about the initial impacts of Covid-19 on MÄori-medium education and how the sector responded.
The evaluation approach has been designed by MÄori, with MÄori, for MÄori and in te reo MÄori. It respectfully acknowledges and validates the underlying principles of the differing provisions of MÄori-medium education for Te RĹŤnanga Nui o NgÄ Kura Kaupapa MÄori o Aotearoa, NgÄ Kura Ä Iwi o Aotearoa, KĹhanga Reo, Puna Reo and Whare KĹhungahunga, and operates in accordance with these. The above are referred to as peak bodies throughout this report. Information was gathered from learners, whÄnau, kaiako, kaimahi, leaders, hapĹŤ, and iwi representatives.
The MÄori-medium sector has continued to show great success in providing for tamariki MÄori and their whÄnau. The findings demonstrate how those within the sector successfully joined forces with their communities to respond quickly to the many challenges presented by Covid-19, and went above and beyond for learners, whÄnau, hapĹŤ and iwi.
This research found that many learners have come through this period of crisis with their wellbeing and engagement
in learning enhanced by the experience. Leaders and kaiako supported learners and their whÄnau by working with them and remaining connected to them through high levels of whanaungatanga and manaakitanga. Despite the inequities experienced due to a lack of resources and the âdigital divideâ, leaders reported a rise in learner and whÄnau engagement through distance learning.
This report has the potential to be far reaching and can influence the entire education sector. It can serve as a guide to optimising learner engagement and wellbeing in future responses to unprecedented events. Furthermore, the many lessons learnt in MÄori-medium education
can potentially influence English-medium teaching and learning in the future to enhance MÄori achieving educational success as MÄori.
This evaluation acknowledges the similarities from across MÄori-medium education and highlights the value of learning that is grounded in te reo MÄori, tikanga MÄori, te ao MÄori and mÄtauranga MÄori. This research identified best practices and challenges faced by the MÄori-medium education sector in response to the Covid-19 lockdown:
Te Ahi KĹpae:
Leadership
WhÄnau, hapĹŤ, iwi:
MÄori-medium education communities
Ihonui:
the focus and depth of support for wellbeing
Te PĹŤÄhuru:
professional support and guidance
Te MÄpura:
learning and innovation opportunities
inequities that need to be addressed
Â
MÄori-medium education leadership practiced distributive, communal and collaborative engagement. Leaders saw their responsibilities as facilitating the collective actions of whÄnau, iwi, hapĹŤ, community and peak bodies to realise the aspirations and desires for equitable and excellent learner outcomes.
The MÄori-medium community utilised tino rangatiratanga and mana motuhake through high levels of shared responsibility, communication and collaboration, facilitated by whÄnau, iwi, hapĹŤ, community and peak body leaders. This resulted in supportive learning environments and encouraged high levels of learner and whÄnau engagement.
Physical, emotional and spiritual wellbeing of learners and staff, and whÄnau, iwi and hapĹŤ was of paramount importance to the MÄori-medium education paradigm. This, coupled with a strong focus on staying connected to each other, ensured an effective response to the diverse needs of all learners and their whÄnau.
Peak body group members and leaders in MÄori-medium education provided high quality support and timely information to their communities. This supported decision making that was in the best interests of kaiako, learners and their whÄnau. Peak bodies ensured there was provision of professional development to support kaiako in growing their digital capabilities and pedagogy to enhance learning for tamariki.
Learning and innovation was evident in MÄori-medium education. Advances in the digital learning space created differentiated learning opportunities and innovations whilst staying true to the collective goal of promoting te reo, tikanga and mÄtauranga MÄori. Leaders were creative in managing staff workloads, through modifying programmes and timetables, and promoting whÄnau participation in learning. Tamariki acquired greater skills to manage their own learning.
The digital divide was an issue. Leaders reported that it was more difficult to engage learners when they did not have access to an appropriate digital device and internet connection.
There were a number of learners whose whÄnau were disadvantaged due to being unable to communicate with their kura or service provider. The provision of hard pack resources for MÄori- medium education was often not appropriate for learners and was not of the quality expected
to promote and enhance language, culture and identity. In addressing these challenges many leaders reported that they and kaiako used creative approaches to address the digital divide using other platforms and approaches to share, connect and communicate with learners and whÄnau.
This evaluation acknowledges the similarities from across MÄori-medium education and highlights the value of learning that is grounded in te reo MÄori, tikanga MÄori, te ao MÄori and mÄtauranga MÄori. This research identified best practices and challenges faced by the MÄori-medium education sector in response to the Covid-19 lockdown:
Te Ahi KĹpae:
Leadership
WhÄnau, hapĹŤ, iwi:
MÄori-medium education communities
Ihonui:
the focus and depth of support for wellbeing
Te PĹŤÄhuru:
professional support and guidance
Te MÄpura:
learning and innovation opportunities
inequities that need to be addressed
Â
MÄori-medium education leadership practiced distributive, communal and collaborative engagement. Leaders saw their responsibilities as facilitating the collective actions of whÄnau, iwi, hapĹŤ, community and peak bodies to realise the aspirations and desires for equitable and excellent learner outcomes.
The MÄori-medium community utilised tino rangatiratanga and mana motuhake through high levels of shared responsibility, communication and collaboration, facilitated by whÄnau, iwi, hapĹŤ, community and peak body leaders. This resulted in supportive learning environments and encouraged high levels of learner and whÄnau engagement.
Physical, emotional and spiritual wellbeing of learners and staff, and whÄnau, iwi and hapĹŤ was of paramount importance to the MÄori-medium education paradigm. This, coupled with a strong focus on staying connected to each other, ensured an effective response to the diverse needs of all learners and their whÄnau.
Peak body group members and leaders in MÄori-medium education provided high quality support and timely information to their communities. This supported decision making that was in the best interests of kaiako, learners and their whÄnau. Peak bodies ensured there was provision of professional development to support kaiako in growing their digital capabilities and pedagogy to enhance learning for tamariki.
Learning and innovation was evident in MÄori-medium education. Advances in the digital learning space created differentiated learning opportunities and innovations whilst staying true to the collective goal of promoting te reo, tikanga and mÄtauranga MÄori. Leaders were creative in managing staff workloads, through modifying programmes and timetables, and promoting whÄnau participation in learning. Tamariki acquired greater skills to manage their own learning.
The digital divide was an issue. Leaders reported that it was more difficult to engage learners when they did not have access to an appropriate digital device and internet connection.
There were a number of learners whose whÄnau were disadvantaged due to being unable to communicate with their kura or service provider. The provision of hard pack resources for MÄori- medium education was often not appropriate for learners and was not of the quality expected
to promote and enhance language, culture and identity. In addressing these challenges many leaders reported that they and kaiako used creative approaches to address the digital divide using other platforms and approaches to share, connect and communicate with learners and whÄnau.
No one could have anticipated what unfolded at the beginning of 2020. Covid-19 represents a substantial and alarming threat to health and livelihoods throughout Aotearoa and the world. The global pandemic resulted in a nationwide state of emergency. On 25 March 2020, New Zealand went into lockdown under Alert Level 4 with very little warning.
For the education sector, this meant all educational facilities were closed, which caused short- term disruption to studentsâ learning and wellbeing. With little to no indication of how long
it would be before the sector could return to normal, it was important for everyone to adjust quickly to the changes and do what was required to ensure student learning and wellbeing could continue as best as possible from home.
In response to the situation, ERO undertook a programme of work to understand the response of the MÄori-medium sector during Alert Levels 1-4. MÄori-medium education is the term used throughout this report to describe those settings that provide education reflecting te reo MÄori, tikanga MÄori, mÄtauranga MÄori, and te ao MÄori.
This evaluation sought to better understand the impacts of Covid-19 across MÄori-medium education. Te Pou Mataaho aimed to capture the stories, lessons, challenges and innovations as MÄori-medium education providers navigated through the phases of Covid-19 from Alert Level 4 to Alert Level 1. The purpose was to ensure that the results of this evaluation would influence future decision making in MÄori-medium education to further enhance outcomes for learners and their whÄnau.
This work was undertaken with our sector partners in MÄori-medium education. We committed to work with, for, as and by MÄori, and in te reo MÄori.
To maintain our purpose we focused on universal themes that reflect the uniqueness of the MÄori-medium paradigm. These themes were selected as a part of the initial discussions with peak bodies, taking individual contexts into consideration.
Te Pou Mataaho and Te UepĹŤ Ä-Motu worked with their partners Te KĹhanga Reo National Trust, Te RĹŤnanga Nui o NgÄ Kura Kaupapa MÄori o Aotearoa and NgÄ Kura Ä Iwi o Aotearoa. Together it was decided to focus this research on compiling innovations, concerns, issues or matters of interest. It was agreed that stories would be captured and shared to guide future decision making and learning.
The evaluation approach included three phases to uphold the integrity of the te ao MÄori influence. These phases are:
It was agreed that this research and its findings would contribute to the way ERO and the MÄori- medium sector work together in the future. Particularly, considering the immediate, medium and long-term implications of the Covid-19 disruption for Äkonga.
The initial evaluation, developed in collaboration with the aforementioned peak bodies, identified the following significant themes:
Using these themes as a foundation, the research team conducted a series of comprehensive evaluations that covered four key sectors that were representative of 132 MÄori learning communities in Te KĹhanga Reo National Trust, NgÄ Kura Ä Iwi o Aotearoa, Te RĹŤnanga Nui
o NgÄ Kura Kaupapa MÄori o Aotearoa and Puna Reo or Whare KĹhungahunga.
The research included qualitative and quantitative data from surveys, meetings, interviews, document analysis and videoconferencing hui. These were conducted with leaders, kaiako, learners and their whÄnau. The structured interviews focused on individual contexts. In addition, the peak body groups had opportunities to provide feedback and recommendations for improvements as the process evolved.
Te Pou Mataaho and Te UepĹŤ Ä-Motu analysed responses for each of the four sectors and produced summary reports that captured their unique experiences in relation to the evaluation purpose.
This report acknowledges Te RĹŤnanga Nui o NgÄ Kura Kaupapa MÄori o Aotearoa, NgÄ Kura Ä Iwi o Aotearoa, KĹhanga Reo and Puna Reo or Whare KĹhungahunga for the strength of their
philosophical underpinnings and connections to the communities they serve. Despite each being unique in context and active participants in tino rangatiratanga (autonomy) and mana motuhake (independence), the data can be used collectively as representative of the impacts on and responses of the MÄori-medium education sector in relation to Covid-19.
MÄori medium | Whanaungatanga | Whakaaetanga | Whakataunga |
---|---|---|---|
Puna Reo 30 |
Collaboration, discussions and support Agreement |
Leadership and whÄnau support | Agreement |
KĹhanga Reo 80 |
Collaboration, discussions and support |
Te KĹhanga Reo National Trust, district, whÄnau support |
Agreement |
Te Aho Matua Kura Kaupapa MÄori |
Collaboration, discussions and support |
Te RĹŤnanga Nui or NgÄ Kura Kaupapa MÄori o Aotearoa, kura, whÄnau, leadership support | Agreement |
NgÄ Kura Ä Iwi 8 |
Collaboration, discussions and support |
NgÄ KuraÂ Ä Iwi, kura, whÄnau, leadership support |
Agreement |
No one could have anticipated what unfolded at the beginning of 2020. Covid-19 represents a substantial and alarming threat to health and livelihoods throughout Aotearoa and the world. The global pandemic resulted in a nationwide state of emergency. On 25 March 2020, New Zealand went into lockdown under Alert Level 4 with very little warning.
For the education sector, this meant all educational facilities were closed, which caused short- term disruption to studentsâ learning and wellbeing. With little to no indication of how long
it would be before the sector could return to normal, it was important for everyone to adjust quickly to the changes and do what was required to ensure student learning and wellbeing could continue as best as possible from home.
In response to the situation, ERO undertook a programme of work to understand the response of the MÄori-medium sector during Alert Levels 1-4. MÄori-medium education is the term used throughout this report to describe those settings that provide education reflecting te reo MÄori, tikanga MÄori, mÄtauranga MÄori, and te ao MÄori.
This evaluation sought to better understand the impacts of Covid-19 across MÄori-medium education. Te Pou Mataaho aimed to capture the stories, lessons, challenges and innovations as MÄori-medium education providers navigated through the phases of Covid-19 from Alert Level 4 to Alert Level 1. The purpose was to ensure that the results of this evaluation would influence future decision making in MÄori-medium education to further enhance outcomes for learners and their whÄnau.
This work was undertaken with our sector partners in MÄori-medium education. We committed to work with, for, as and by MÄori, and in te reo MÄori.
To maintain our purpose we focused on universal themes that reflect the uniqueness of the MÄori-medium paradigm. These themes were selected as a part of the initial discussions with peak bodies, taking individual contexts into consideration.
Te Pou Mataaho and Te UepĹŤ Ä-Motu worked with their partners Te KĹhanga Reo National Trust, Te RĹŤnanga Nui o NgÄ Kura Kaupapa MÄori o Aotearoa and NgÄ Kura Ä Iwi o Aotearoa. Together it was decided to focus this research on compiling innovations, concerns, issues or matters of interest. It was agreed that stories would be captured and shared to guide future decision making and learning.
The evaluation approach included three phases to uphold the integrity of the te ao MÄori influence. These phases are:
It was agreed that this research and its findings would contribute to the way ERO and the MÄori- medium sector work together in the future. Particularly, considering the immediate, medium and long-term implications of the Covid-19 disruption for Äkonga.
The initial evaluation, developed in collaboration with the aforementioned peak bodies, identified the following significant themes:
Using these themes as a foundation, the research team conducted a series of comprehensive evaluations that covered four key sectors that were representative of 132 MÄori learning communities in Te KĹhanga Reo National Trust, NgÄ Kura Ä Iwi o Aotearoa, Te RĹŤnanga Nui
o NgÄ Kura Kaupapa MÄori o Aotearoa and Puna Reo or Whare KĹhungahunga.
The research included qualitative and quantitative data from surveys, meetings, interviews, document analysis and videoconferencing hui. These were conducted with leaders, kaiako, learners and their whÄnau. The structured interviews focused on individual contexts. In addition, the peak body groups had opportunities to provide feedback and recommendations for improvements as the process evolved.
Te Pou Mataaho and Te UepĹŤ Ä-Motu analysed responses for each of the four sectors and produced summary reports that captured their unique experiences in relation to the evaluation purpose.
This report acknowledges Te RĹŤnanga Nui o NgÄ Kura Kaupapa MÄori o Aotearoa, NgÄ Kura Ä Iwi o Aotearoa, KĹhanga Reo and Puna Reo or Whare KĹhungahunga for the strength of their
philosophical underpinnings and connections to the communities they serve. Despite each being unique in context and active participants in tino rangatiratanga (autonomy) and mana motuhake (independence), the data can be used collectively as representative of the impacts on and responses of the MÄori-medium education sector in relation to Covid-19.
MÄori medium | Whanaungatanga | Whakaaetanga | Whakataunga |
---|---|---|---|
Puna Reo 30 |
Collaboration, discussions and support Agreement |
Leadership and whÄnau support | Agreement |
KĹhanga Reo 80 |
Collaboration, discussions and support |
Te KĹhanga Reo National Trust, district, whÄnau support |
Agreement |
Te Aho Matua Kura Kaupapa MÄori |
Collaboration, discussions and support |
Te RĹŤnanga Nui or NgÄ Kura Kaupapa MÄori o Aotearoa, kura, whÄnau, leadership support | Agreement |
NgÄ Kura Ä Iwi 8 |
Collaboration, discussions and support |
NgÄ KuraÂ Ä Iwi, kura, whÄnau, leadership support |
Agreement |
The research found that the power of collaboration, embodied in the whakataukÄŤ âEhara taku toa i te toa takitahi, he toa takitini kÄâ, was essential for leadership. There is an unwavering acknowledgement by leaders in MÄori-medium education that their success as leaders is reliant upon the strength and unity of the collective, particularly during the Covid-19 pandemic.During the Covid-19 lockdown, this model of leadership promoted active communication and engagement by key stakeholders, which ultimately contributed to success in a number of areas. Leadership focused on addressing anxieties and concerns, developing and explaining clear expectations, monitoring wellbeing, mitigating financial and staffing risks, establishing collaborative systems and providing procedures for health and safety plans.
The recurring theme that emerged from leadersâ responses is that they sought to collaborate with individuals, groups and organisations, which then informed and guided their decision making. Their methods included hosting numerous virtual meetings with key stakeholders; engaging the services of community, local and central government organisations; and enhancing working relationships with other leaders in the sector.
Ideals such as whanaungatanga (deeply intimate connections) and manaakitanga (unconditional care) were used to assess, monitor and respond to kura and services staff wellbeing. Leaders were acutely aware of their staffâs workloads, particularly during the lockdown period. This was evidently relevant to teachers, administrators and support staff.
Leaders worked collaboratively and creatively with staff to manage workloads, while maintaining engaging, culturally appropriate and educationally purposeful learning opportunities for learners. Common approaches across MÄori-medium education included modifying programmes and timetables, promoting whÄnau participation in learning and seeking relevant and appropriate professional support and development for kaiako.
âWhÄnauâ, in this context, refers to âthe influence and strength of the centre.â âWhÄnauâ is commonly understood simply as âfamilyâ, the deeper understanding of the term within MÄori- medium education is whÄnau as based on shared experiences, shared aspirations, and shared responsibility. This notion encompasses the idea that a MÄori-medium whÄnau consists of the staff within the kura or service, the local marae, iwi and hapĹŤ, and the families whose children were enrolled (raukura or graduates) or whose children are currently enrolled in the kura or service. This includes parents, siblings, aunties, uncles and kaumÄtua (grandparents).
During the Covid-19 lockdown, MÄori communities exercised their tino rangatiratanga and mana motuhake. This is clearly expressed by one respondent who stated:
We do not wait for someone else to help us â
we do it ourselves, with what we have.
Many MÄori-medium kura, kĹhanga or puna provided a space where MÄori whÄnau saw opportunities to practice the idea of âfor MÄori, by MÄori, as MÄoriâ.
A recurring theme articulated by many of the whÄnau interviewed was that the high level of collaboration and communication was key to adequately supporting those who were most vulnerable. This was vital in addressing anxieties and uncertainties among MÄori-medium communities. Ministry of Education bulletin encouraged staff of kura and services to âjust continue being a solid constant in the lives of whÄnau and tamariki.â
There were numerous accounts of whÄnau pooling resources for educational benefits, as well as to mitigate the growing social pressures many whÄnau were facing. Many MÄori-medium education providers and the wider whÄnau were instrumental in providing clear and up-to-date information to their respective communities, hosting wÄnanga to discuss tikanga and policy processes for online learning, self-funding the compilation of resource packs, establishing ways to maintain whanaungatanga and connection, putting together and distributing kai and hygiene packs, and maintaining a level of calmness and unity.
Whilst Covid-19 created a range of educational, social, health and wellbeing pressures, it was also observed that there was a heightened level of whÄnau engagement in children's learning.
MÄori-medium education providers saw increased engagement by whÄnau in the learning process of their tamariki.
WhÄnau voice:
We found time to sit with our tamariki and learn together.Â
Tamariki voice:
I asked for help from my Nana when I needed it but most of the time, I was able to work by myself. I had Zoom meetings and when I did classwork my teachers helped with anything I needed.
This is particularly noticeable around mÄtauranga MÄori, te reo MÄori and MÄori beliefs. The higher levels of engagement with whÄnau at home enhanced the learning journey of young MÄori.
WhÄnau voice:
We focused on what was most important â arÄ te manawa me te wairua o te mokopuna...mÄnÄ kei te ora kare e kore ka tipu mÄtoro Ä hinengaro Ä tinana. Getting the basics right â focusing on our Kaupapa â te reo me Ĺna tikanga.
Ihonui: Wellbeing
Ihonui â wellbeing and wellness â in te ao MÄori includes the physical element and actively integrates spiritual, cognitive and familial connections.
Many of the MÄori-medium education leaders acknowledged that whilst their staff continued in their professional capacities, many of them also felt the pressures of the global pandemic and were simultaneously carrying responsibilities for their own whÄnau.
Wellbeing of staff:
Approaches such as modifications to teaching programmes and timetables helped kaiako better manage workload. This included class Zoom sessions, independent learning activities and one- on-one tutorials that educational leaders and staff implemented with the support of the wider MÄori-medium whÄnau, including their peak bodies. This was done to manage the obvious increase in workload placed upon kaiako and to mitigate the potential of âteacher burnoutâ.
The following is an example of a leaderâs concerns:
Kaiako have worked tirelessly without breaks throughout lockdown and the emotional toll was significant.
Many staff were asked, at extremely short notice, to plan and facilitate learning experiences that were foreign to many of them. Leaders, in collaboration with the various peak bodies, sought relevant and accessible support. For the most part this came in the form of professional development and training around the understanding, navigation and application within the digital technologies space.
Kaiako were not feeling they were adding enough value as they were below par to deliver digitally.
Although adapting to the use of technology presented some challenges, leaders acknowledged the rapid adaptation and innovation of most MÄori-medium staff. They now feel they are much better prepared as a teaching cohort to provide quality and engaging learning opportunities if another lockdown occurs.
Wellbeing of Learners:
The wellbeing of learners was a priority across the MÄori-medium sector with a clear focus on staying connected. This strengthened connections between learner and kaiako; learner and taiao; learner and reo; learner and tikanga; and ultimately, learner and mÄtauranga. With this understanding, educational leaders and kaiako explored multiple opportunities to keep learners connected.
Tamariki voice:
Our kaiako were awesome. They supported us in every way.
Access to digital devices and the internet remained a factor for MÄori-medium education during lockdown and prompted creative approaches from leaders and kaiako to maintain regular contact with learners and whÄnau.
It is important to note that while a number of Ministry of Education âhard packsâ were assembled for learners across Aotearoa, these were not always appropriate for the learnersâ needs and often didnât align with the richness of culture and language that MÄori-medium aspire to provide.
For those families challenged by their ability to communicate with kura or service providers, kaiako embraced different ways to keep in touch, using phone calls, texts and social media to bridge the digital divide. What was shown throughout the MÄori-medium sector was an overwhelming resilience to these challenges, with MÄori students continuing to thrive.
Key to that story of resilience and success is whÄnau deeply engaged in studentsâ learning and kaiako committed to staying connected and responding to the individual needs of each family.
WhÄnau voice:
We kept in touch, we had Facebook and felt like the whÄnau was everywhere at the right time.
WhÄnau voice:
We loved the TV learning opportunity for our kids.
Staying connected proved to be invaluable when New Zealand moved down Alert Levels. Learners were positive about returning to their respective educational providers and did not feel disconnected. Research found there was a general sense of relief and joy expressed by the learners upon return to their respective kura or service.
Wellbeing of WhÄnau:
Leaders clearly took on a lot of additional responsibility in the form of communication with whÄnau, as well as networking and collaborating with various community and government services that could provide support to whÄnau.
WhÄnau voice:
We are and will be well prepared if lockdown is to happen again with a better understanding.
WhÄnau benefitted from MÄori-medium leaders working to collaborate, communicate and coordinate with entities such as KidsCan, Breakfast Club, Fruit in Schools, WhÄnau Ora, Ministry of Health and other localised community initiatives. Furthermore, they also worked closely with local marae, hapĹŤÂ and iwi to ensure the most vulnerable whÄnau had access to support.
In the short term, the focus was on some of the basic needs such as food, hygiene supplies, blankets and warm clothing. This provided a strong sense of whanaungatanga.
Leader voice:
The contributions of these initiatives and that of whÄnau, hapĹŤÂ and iwi to these packs was invaluable.
Te PĹŤÄhuru: Professional Support
Te PĹŤÄhuru is the idea of ânew concepts that reinforces or builds on and enhances oneâs understanding and promotes a feeling of warmth, confidence and satisfaction. The support whether it is personal or professional shouldâ evoke a âfire in your bellyâ and the need to know more.â
The peak bodies provided guidance and advocacy for the various MÄori-medium providers. This was critical in ensuring that kura, services and leaders were well informed and supported. These actions helped reduce the workload of the leaders in that space, which allowed them to focus on supporting uri, kaiako, whÄnau and their communities.
WhÄnau voice:
We are ready to go. Our whÄnau are ready. Big ups to [governing body] they sent through all the guidance.Â
Those within MÄori-medium education expressed appreciation to their leaders for the creation of national guidelines and sharing best practices in response to Covid-19. They also acknowledged support from the Ministry of Education and MÄori Advisors as critical to enabling the peak bodies, leaders and MÄori-medium to provide information and support to their communities.
Leader voice:
Those Covid-19 updates were my guiding light. I was able to get a good sense of where to take the kura. The updates were clear and direct.Â
MÄori-medium education providers quickly realised they had several vulnerabilities in relation to distance or remote learning. Not all staff were confident in the use, navigation, and application of various digital technologies and platforms. The peak bodies and leaders sought opportunities for staff to build or enhance their understanding of the capabilities and applications of digital technologies and platforms. This was done in collaboration with teachers to ensure the professional development was both fit for purpose and catered directly to the practical and immediate needs of its users.
This included broadening the application of existing platforms used by various MÄori-medium education providers, such as Google Classroom, Microsoft Teams, Class Dojo, SeeSaw and Zoom. PLD (professional learning and development) for existing platforms was often facilitated internally by more confident and competent staff members. It also included working with PLD providers such as Core Education, Evaluation Associates, PB4L and MindLab. PLD was also provided for wellbeing programmes, giving staff more opportunities to integrate wellbeing into their distance learning programme.
MÄori-medium education staff invested large amounts of time and energy into developing themselves as distance learning practitioners under tight time frames. There was a good level of innovation and creativity happening across the various sectors in a collaborative manner.
Kaiako explored the opportunities that digital technology could provide for the advancement of revitalising te reo MÄori. There was a sense of a newfound âfire in the bellyâ with a workforce that looked to launch MÄori-medium education into the future.
Te MÄpura: Learning and Innovation
Te MÄpura is described as âsmall sparks that often come out of nowhere from the heart of the fire, but create a chain reaction, much like how one idea can create a chain reaction of innovation and creativity.â
Learning and innovation in relation to the use and application of digital technology was essential and MÄori-medium providers had little choice but to be innovative. Providers recognised the energy and effort that was invested leading up to, during and even post the major lockdown period.
As a result of the integration of more digital learning platforms and experiences, there was a noticeable increase in engagement by both whÄnau and learners not affected by the digital divide. Many whÄnau members became active learners with their tamariki, especially those that didnât speak te reo MÄori. They found that they could revisit recorded lessons and access activities and online learning platforms from the safety of their own home.
Â
Leader voice:
This is a positive for whÄnau engagement because non-MÄori speaking whÄnau recorded themselves speaking MÄori with their tamariki and posted videos on Facebook.Â
Familiarity with the digital technologies increased opportunities for whÄnau engagement. The lockdown and distance learning experience proved to be a catalyst which sparked a new and innovative way of thinking about engagement.
Tamariki voice:
I loved being on Facebook for karakia.
The increased levels of learner engagement with the integration of more digital technologies was clear across the MÄori-medium sector. There were a number of factors that contributed to this, including: the younger generation having greater familiarity with digital learning; a greater variety of tools and strategies available for learners; and teachers becoming more creative with their lessons and activities. There might also be a link between the increased engagement of whÄnau in their children's learning and the increased engagement of the children themselves.
Tamariki voice:
I was able to plan my own learning programme and my kaiako supported me to be adventurous.
With the recognition of this increased level of engagement, many MÄori-medium providers have sought to continue with the digital style learning platforms and resources post-lockdown.
There are numerous ways in which these practices have continued, such as recording karakia and waiata and posting on online platforms, sharing children's learning live through social media channels, and disseminating tutorials and activities through online platforms. There has also been an increase in the use of communicative tools such as Zoom to allow more whÄnau to engage in whÄnau hui.
Â
The research found that the power of collaboration, embodied in the whakataukÄŤ âEhara taku toa i te toa takitahi, he toa takitini kÄâ, was essential for leadership. There is an unwavering acknowledgement by leaders in MÄori-medium education that their success as leaders is reliant upon the strength and unity of the collective, particularly during the Covid-19 pandemic.During the Covid-19 lockdown, this model of leadership promoted active communication and engagement by key stakeholders, which ultimately contributed to success in a number of areas. Leadership focused on addressing anxieties and concerns, developing and explaining clear expectations, monitoring wellbeing, mitigating financial and staffing risks, establishing collaborative systems and providing procedures for health and safety plans.
The recurring theme that emerged from leadersâ responses is that they sought to collaborate with individuals, groups and organisations, which then informed and guided their decision making. Their methods included hosting numerous virtual meetings with key stakeholders; engaging the services of community, local and central government organisations; and enhancing working relationships with other leaders in the sector.
Ideals such as whanaungatanga (deeply intimate connections) and manaakitanga (unconditional care) were used to assess, monitor and respond to kura and services staff wellbeing. Leaders were acutely aware of their staffâs workloads, particularly during the lockdown period. This was evidently relevant to teachers, administrators and support staff.
Leaders worked collaboratively and creatively with staff to manage workloads, while maintaining engaging, culturally appropriate and educationally purposeful learning opportunities for learners. Common approaches across MÄori-medium education included modifying programmes and timetables, promoting whÄnau participation in learning and seeking relevant and appropriate professional support and development for kaiako.
âWhÄnauâ, in this context, refers to âthe influence and strength of the centre.â âWhÄnauâ is commonly understood simply as âfamilyâ, the deeper understanding of the term within MÄori- medium education is whÄnau as based on shared experiences, shared aspirations, and shared responsibility. This notion encompasses the idea that a MÄori-medium whÄnau consists of the staff within the kura or service, the local marae, iwi and hapĹŤ, and the families whose children were enrolled (raukura or graduates) or whose children are currently enrolled in the kura or service. This includes parents, siblings, aunties, uncles and kaumÄtua (grandparents).
During the Covid-19 lockdown, MÄori communities exercised their tino rangatiratanga and mana motuhake. This is clearly expressed by one respondent who stated:
We do not wait for someone else to help us â
we do it ourselves, with what we have.
Many MÄori-medium kura, kĹhanga or puna provided a space where MÄori whÄnau saw opportunities to practice the idea of âfor MÄori, by MÄori, as MÄoriâ.
A recurring theme articulated by many of the whÄnau interviewed was that the high level of collaboration and communication was key to adequately supporting those who were most vulnerable. This was vital in addressing anxieties and uncertainties among MÄori-medium communities. Ministry of Education bulletin encouraged staff of kura and services to âjust continue being a solid constant in the lives of whÄnau and tamariki.â
There were numerous accounts of whÄnau pooling resources for educational benefits, as well as to mitigate the growing social pressures many whÄnau were facing. Many MÄori-medium education providers and the wider whÄnau were instrumental in providing clear and up-to-date information to their respective communities, hosting wÄnanga to discuss tikanga and policy processes for online learning, self-funding the compilation of resource packs, establishing ways to maintain whanaungatanga and connection, putting together and distributing kai and hygiene packs, and maintaining a level of calmness and unity.
Whilst Covid-19 created a range of educational, social, health and wellbeing pressures, it was also observed that there was a heightened level of whÄnau engagement in children's learning.
MÄori-medium education providers saw increased engagement by whÄnau in the learning process of their tamariki.
WhÄnau voice:
We found time to sit with our tamariki and learn together.Â
Tamariki voice:
I asked for help from my Nana when I needed it but most of the time, I was able to work by myself. I had Zoom meetings and when I did classwork my teachers helped with anything I needed.
This is particularly noticeable around mÄtauranga MÄori, te reo MÄori and MÄori beliefs. The higher levels of engagement with whÄnau at home enhanced the learning journey of young MÄori.
WhÄnau voice:
We focused on what was most important â arÄ te manawa me te wairua o te mokopuna...mÄnÄ kei te ora kare e kore ka tipu mÄtoro Ä hinengaro Ä tinana. Getting the basics right â focusing on our Kaupapa â te reo me Ĺna tikanga.
Ihonui: Wellbeing
Ihonui â wellbeing and wellness â in te ao MÄori includes the physical element and actively integrates spiritual, cognitive and familial connections.
Many of the MÄori-medium education leaders acknowledged that whilst their staff continued in their professional capacities, many of them also felt the pressures of the global pandemic and were simultaneously carrying responsibilities for their own whÄnau.
Wellbeing of staff:
Approaches such as modifications to teaching programmes and timetables helped kaiako better manage workload. This included class Zoom sessions, independent learning activities and one- on-one tutorials that educational leaders and staff implemented with the support of the wider MÄori-medium whÄnau, including their peak bodies. This was done to manage the obvious increase in workload placed upon kaiako and to mitigate the potential of âteacher burnoutâ.
The following is an example of a leaderâs concerns:
Kaiako have worked tirelessly without breaks throughout lockdown and the emotional toll was significant.
Many staff were asked, at extremely short notice, to plan and facilitate learning experiences that were foreign to many of them. Leaders, in collaboration with the various peak bodies, sought relevant and accessible support. For the most part this came in the form of professional development and training around the understanding, navigation and application within the digital technologies space.
Kaiako were not feeling they were adding enough value as they were below par to deliver digitally.
Although adapting to the use of technology presented some challenges, leaders acknowledged the rapid adaptation and innovation of most MÄori-medium staff. They now feel they are much better prepared as a teaching cohort to provide quality and engaging learning opportunities if another lockdown occurs.
Wellbeing of Learners:
The wellbeing of learners was a priority across the MÄori-medium sector with a clear focus on staying connected. This strengthened connections between learner and kaiako; learner and taiao; learner and reo; learner and tikanga; and ultimately, learner and mÄtauranga. With this understanding, educational leaders and kaiako explored multiple opportunities to keep learners connected.
Tamariki voice:
Our kaiako were awesome. They supported us in every way.
Access to digital devices and the internet remained a factor for MÄori-medium education during lockdown and prompted creative approaches from leaders and kaiako to maintain regular contact with learners and whÄnau.
It is important to note that while a number of Ministry of Education âhard packsâ were assembled for learners across Aotearoa, these were not always appropriate for the learnersâ needs and often didnât align with the richness of culture and language that MÄori-medium aspire to provide.
For those families challenged by their ability to communicate with kura or service providers, kaiako embraced different ways to keep in touch, using phone calls, texts and social media to bridge the digital divide. What was shown throughout the MÄori-medium sector was an overwhelming resilience to these challenges, with MÄori students continuing to thrive.
Key to that story of resilience and success is whÄnau deeply engaged in studentsâ learning and kaiako committed to staying connected and responding to the individual needs of each family.
WhÄnau voice:
We kept in touch, we had Facebook and felt like the whÄnau was everywhere at the right time.
WhÄnau voice:
We loved the TV learning opportunity for our kids.
Staying connected proved to be invaluable when New Zealand moved down Alert Levels. Learners were positive about returning to their respective educational providers and did not feel disconnected. Research found there was a general sense of relief and joy expressed by the learners upon return to their respective kura or service.
Wellbeing of WhÄnau:
Leaders clearly took on a lot of additional responsibility in the form of communication with whÄnau, as well as networking and collaborating with various community and government services that could provide support to whÄnau.
WhÄnau voice:
We are and will be well prepared if lockdown is to happen again with a better understanding.
WhÄnau benefitted from MÄori-medium leaders working to collaborate, communicate and coordinate with entities such as KidsCan, Breakfast Club, Fruit in Schools, WhÄnau Ora, Ministry of Health and other localised community initiatives. Furthermore, they also worked closely with local marae, hapĹŤÂ and iwi to ensure the most vulnerable whÄnau had access to support.
In the short term, the focus was on some of the basic needs such as food, hygiene supplies, blankets and warm clothing. This provided a strong sense of whanaungatanga.
Leader voice:
The contributions of these initiatives and that of whÄnau, hapĹŤÂ and iwi to these packs was invaluable.
Te PĹŤÄhuru: Professional Support
Te PĹŤÄhuru is the idea of ânew concepts that reinforces or builds on and enhances oneâs understanding and promotes a feeling of warmth, confidence and satisfaction. The support whether it is personal or professional shouldâ evoke a âfire in your bellyâ and the need to know more.â
The peak bodies provided guidance and advocacy for the various MÄori-medium providers. This was critical in ensuring that kura, services and leaders were well informed and supported. These actions helped reduce the workload of the leaders in that space, which allowed them to focus on supporting uri, kaiako, whÄnau and their communities.
WhÄnau voice:
We are ready to go. Our whÄnau are ready. Big ups to [governing body] they sent through all the guidance.Â
Those within MÄori-medium education expressed appreciation to their leaders for the creation of national guidelines and sharing best practices in response to Covid-19. They also acknowledged support from the Ministry of Education and MÄori Advisors as critical to enabling the peak bodies, leaders and MÄori-medium to provide information and support to their communities.
Leader voice:
Those Covid-19 updates were my guiding light. I was able to get a good sense of where to take the kura. The updates were clear and direct.Â
MÄori-medium education providers quickly realised they had several vulnerabilities in relation to distance or remote learning. Not all staff were confident in the use, navigation, and application of various digital technologies and platforms. The peak bodies and leaders sought opportunities for staff to build or enhance their understanding of the capabilities and applications of digital technologies and platforms. This was done in collaboration with teachers to ensure the professional development was both fit for purpose and catered directly to the practical and immediate needs of its users.
This included broadening the application of existing platforms used by various MÄori-medium education providers, such as Google Classroom, Microsoft Teams, Class Dojo, SeeSaw and Zoom. PLD (professional learning and development) for existing platforms was often facilitated internally by more confident and competent staff members. It also included working with PLD providers such as Core Education, Evaluation Associates, PB4L and MindLab. PLD was also provided for wellbeing programmes, giving staff more opportunities to integrate wellbeing into their distance learning programme.
MÄori-medium education staff invested large amounts of time and energy into developing themselves as distance learning practitioners under tight time frames. There was a good level of innovation and creativity happening across the various sectors in a collaborative manner.
Kaiako explored the opportunities that digital technology could provide for the advancement of revitalising te reo MÄori. There was a sense of a newfound âfire in the bellyâ with a workforce that looked to launch MÄori-medium education into the future.
Te MÄpura: Learning and Innovation
Te MÄpura is described as âsmall sparks that often come out of nowhere from the heart of the fire, but create a chain reaction, much like how one idea can create a chain reaction of innovation and creativity.â
Learning and innovation in relation to the use and application of digital technology was essential and MÄori-medium providers had little choice but to be innovative. Providers recognised the energy and effort that was invested leading up to, during and even post the major lockdown period.
As a result of the integration of more digital learning platforms and experiences, there was a noticeable increase in engagement by both whÄnau and learners not affected by the digital divide. Many whÄnau members became active learners with their tamariki, especially those that didnât speak te reo MÄori. They found that they could revisit recorded lessons and access activities and online learning platforms from the safety of their own home.
Â
Leader voice:
This is a positive for whÄnau engagement because non-MÄori speaking whÄnau recorded themselves speaking MÄori with their tamariki and posted videos on Facebook.Â
Familiarity with the digital technologies increased opportunities for whÄnau engagement. The lockdown and distance learning experience proved to be a catalyst which sparked a new and innovative way of thinking about engagement.
Tamariki voice:
I loved being on Facebook for karakia.
The increased levels of learner engagement with the integration of more digital technologies was clear across the MÄori-medium sector. There were a number of factors that contributed to this, including: the younger generation having greater familiarity with digital learning; a greater variety of tools and strategies available for learners; and teachers becoming more creative with their lessons and activities. There might also be a link between the increased engagement of whÄnau in their children's learning and the increased engagement of the children themselves.
Tamariki voice:
I was able to plan my own learning programme and my kaiako supported me to be adventurous.
With the recognition of this increased level of engagement, many MÄori-medium providers have sought to continue with the digital style learning platforms and resources post-lockdown.
There are numerous ways in which these practices have continued, such as recording karakia and waiata and posting on online platforms, sharing children's learning live through social media channels, and disseminating tutorials and activities through online platforms. There has also been an increase in the use of communicative tools such as Zoom to allow more whÄnau to engage in whÄnau hui.
Â
EROâs findings show MÄori-medium learners were more engaged and more likely to experience wellbeing and continuity of learning when certain systems, practices and conditions were evident prior to, and during Covid-19 Alert Levels 1-4. These included:
MÄori communities kept connected and upheld tikanga practices. Kaiako across the motu shared teaching and learning resources, and whÄnau supported authentic and exciting home-life learning experiences.
The opportunity going forward is for ERO and its partners â Te KĹhanga Reo, Te RĹŤnanga Nui o NgÄ Kura Kaupapa MÄori o Aotearoa and NgÄ Kura Ä Iwi o Aotearoa â to use the insights from this evaluation to assist kura and services to be better prepared to deliver distance learning
in uncertain times. The creation of more resources and improved access to technology in MÄori-medium education is critical. The findings highlight the opportunity to harness and
share â across both MÄori-medium and English-medium education â the effective teaching and learning practices already occurring in te ao MÄori, and enhancing MÄori achieving educational success as MÄori.
EROâs findings show MÄori-medium learners were more engaged and more likely to experience wellbeing and continuity of learning when certain systems, practices and conditions were evident prior to, and during Covid-19 Alert Levels 1-4. These included:
MÄori communities kept connected and upheld tikanga practices. Kaiako across the motu shared teaching and learning resources, and whÄnau supported authentic and exciting home-life learning experiences.
The opportunity going forward is for ERO and its partners â Te KĹhanga Reo, Te RĹŤnanga Nui o NgÄ Kura Kaupapa MÄori o Aotearoa and NgÄ Kura Ä Iwi o Aotearoa â to use the insights from this evaluation to assist kura and services to be better prepared to deliver distance learning
in uncertain times. The creation of more resources and improved access to technology in MÄori-medium education is critical. The findings highlight the opportunity to harness and
share â across both MÄori-medium and English-medium education â the effective teaching and learning practices already occurring in te ao MÄori, and enhancing MÄori achieving educational success as MÄori.
Covid-19 created a multitude of challenges for those in MÄori-medium education and the long- term impacts of this global pandemic are not yet fully understood. What is clear and worthy of recognition is the way in which those in MÄori-medium education responded to such challenges and led by example for the wider education sector.
Leaders demonstrated unwavering levels of care and support to learners, their staff and whÄnau, hapĹŤÂ and iwi, which engendered high levels of learner and whÄnau engagement in distance learning.
The MÄori-medium sector worked effectively to ensure learners and whÄnau were well connected and supported, not only in their learning, but also in ensuring whÄnau wellbeing. Educators worked to find solutions in difficult circumstances. Their work was supported through the leadership of the peak bodies and by collaboration among educators, whÄnau, hapĹŤÂ and iwi and other service providers. A positive shift was the enhanced engagement of whÄnau learning alongside tamariki, through te reo, tikanga and mÄtauranga MÄori.
The MÄori-medium education paradigm is integral to providing authentic spaces for young learners, their whÄnau, hapĹŤÂ and iwi to interact; to feel innately and intrinsically connected; to have their holistic wellbeing acknowledged and cared for; to develop their linguistic and cultural capabilities and ultimately to be engaged, creative, and excited learners who can stand confidently and as MÄori in this ever-changing world.
Ko te huarahi MÄori kia mau, ko te huarahi MÄori kia ita, ko te huarahi MÄori kia puta ki te whei ao, ki te ao mÄrama.
Covid-19 created a multitude of challenges for those in MÄori-medium education and the long- term impacts of this global pandemic are not yet fully understood. What is clear and worthy of recognition is the way in which those in MÄori-medium education responded to such challenges and led by example for the wider education sector.
Leaders demonstrated unwavering levels of care and support to learners, their staff and whÄnau, hapĹŤÂ and iwi, which engendered high levels of learner and whÄnau engagement in distance learning.
The MÄori-medium sector worked effectively to ensure learners and whÄnau were well connected and supported, not only in their learning, but also in ensuring whÄnau wellbeing. Educators worked to find solutions in difficult circumstances. Their work was supported through the leadership of the peak bodies and by collaboration among educators, whÄnau, hapĹŤÂ and iwi and other service providers. A positive shift was the enhanced engagement of whÄnau learning alongside tamariki, through te reo, tikanga and mÄtauranga MÄori.
The MÄori-medium education paradigm is integral to providing authentic spaces for young learners, their whÄnau, hapĹŤÂ and iwi to interact; to feel innately and intrinsically connected; to have their holistic wellbeing acknowledged and cared for; to develop their linguistic and cultural capabilities and ultimately to be engaged, creative, and excited learners who can stand confidently and as MÄori in this ever-changing world.
Ko te huarahi MÄori kia mau, ko te huarahi MÄori kia ita, ko te huarahi MÄori kia puta ki te whei ao, ki te ao mÄrama.